How Researching Heavy Metal and Goth Makes an Impact
Karl Spracklen is a Professor of Music, Leisure and Culture at Leeds Beckett University. His research interests include music, subcultures and identity. Here, Professor Karl Spracklen discusses the real impact of research on metal music.
I am fortunate to be involved in two book series with Emerald. I am the co-editor of Alternativity and Marginalization, which explores the meaning and purpose of the alternative and marginal in culture and society. One of the first books in the series is one I have co-authored with Beverley Spracklen called The Evolution of Goth Culture. In this book, we use the idea of collective memory to explore the controversies and boundary-making surrounding the genesis and progression of the modern gothic alternative culture. We suggest that the only way for goth culture to survive is if it becomes transgressive and radical again. In the period before we put the book together we spent time debating the future of goth with a number of people from the goth scene. That is, goths have approached us because we had written other work on goth. This interaction with critical-minded goths led me to be involved on panel at the first Goth City Music Festival in November 2016. Debating with these goths is a sound way to feel one’s research is being read and being critically examined.
The second Emerald book series I am involved with is Studies in Metal Music and Culture, on which I serve on the International Advisory Board. I have been doing research on heavy metal for a number of years, and have been closely involved in the setting up of the International Society for Metal Music Studies (ISMMS). I was the creator and I am now the editor of the journal Metal Music Studies. ISMMS has hundreds of members from around the world, and not just academics. We are proud that professional musicians, journalists and fans are formally part of ISMMS and the wider networks of metal music studies. For academics in ISMMS, the hardest piece of advocacy is convincing people in our faculty organisations and subject fields that heavy metal is worthy of being studied. We have won that argument by having book series like the one on Metal Music and Culture, and by having regular and well-attended conferences and other events around the world.
All this activity on metal music studies demonstrates the impact our research can make. Fans, musicians and others in the music industry are reading the books and the journal articles. My own research on whiteness and hegemonic masculinity (Spracklen, K. (2015). ‘To Holmgard… and Beyond’: Folk metal fantasies and hegemonic white masculinities. Metal Music Studies, 1(3), 359-377.) generated an enormous amount of negative criticism from people who did not want their music labelled a bit racist, and a bit sexist. I cannot point to a causal connection between that paper and a recent trend in metal to challenge the sexism and racism in the scene, but the controversy around that paper and others like it have allowed progressive, alternative visions of heavy metal to emerge.
Would you like to contribute to our Real Impact blog? Find out how.
Recent News & Blogs
- Discover impact news from across the globe
Over a year on from the safeguarding and abuse scandals that rocked Oxfam, Save the Children, Medecins sans Frontieres and revealed challenges across the whole Aid Agency sector, and despite their intention in an open letter of ‘continuing to deliver vital aid but also changing fundamentally.’ the UK International development committee finds too little has …Read Article
The Rise of the Radical Right: Reflections on the Role of Academics in Tracking Emerging DevelopmentsDr William Allchorn - Policy
In recent years radical right actors – which encompasses nativist, authoritarian and populist political movements; both in the global north and parts of the south – are never too far from the headlines. Whether it is the atrocities that took place in Christchurch in March or the hype surrounding Matteo Salvini’s recently announced grouping in …Read Article
The drive towards research needing to demonstrate social benefit has gathered pace in recent years. Impact is now a substantive part of research life for many; to varying degrees, understood, accepted, embedded, integrated, internalised, loved, cherished, or indeed reviled with a fervent passion. But it’s here, and we’ve slowly gotten accustomed to it. As a …Read Article